Cookies
Decorated Sugar Cookies

Our custom decorated sugar cookies are soft, vanilla sugar cookies decorated with royal icing.

We bake and decorate our cookies to order so they stay moist and delicious.

Pricing is generally $36/dozen but can be more if the design is complicated.

Some designs can be done in buttercream, also starting at $36/dozen.

We offer bagging cookies individually for an additional $3/dozen.

Specialty Cookies

We have a great selection of delicious cookies every day, but they can also be pre-ordered in the varieties you like best!  These are large, 3"-4" cookies.  Choose from the following varieties:

$2.50 each-Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Snickerdoodle

$2.75 each-Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Pecan, Churro Cookies

These can also be bagged for $3/dozen


House Made Pies

Maddie's Grandma has always been known for her amazing pies,

and her recipes are now enjoyed at Bumbles!

We have a selection of pies in the shop on Thurs, Friday and Saturday, but you can order them

anytime with just a 48 hour notice.  Give us a call at 614.602.9876 to order or to see what varieties

we have in the case that day!  Our varieties include:

Large 9" - $24            Small 6" - $12

Apple Crumb, Cherry, Mixed Berry, Blueberry, Peanut Butter, Coconut Cream, Key Lime, Banana Cream

Fresh Strawberry (seasonal)


Large 9" - $28            Small 6" - $14

Pecan, Cherry Bourbon, Derby Pie, French Chocolate


2021 Thanksgiving Pies

We are now taking orders for our hand made Thanksgiving pies! 

Pies can be picked up on Tues or Wed of Thanksgiving week. 

We will sell out, so please order early!  This year we are offering the following pies:
Large 9" - $24            Small 6" - $12
Pumpkin, Pumpkin Streusel, Apple Crumb, and Cranberry Berry


Large 9" - $28            Small 6" - $14
Cherry Bourbon (rich cherry filling with bourbon and orange, has almonds in the topping- last year's best seller), 
Pecan (traditional pecan with beautifully arranged pecans on top),

Maple Cream (custardy filling and a slightly salty walnut crust to balance the sweetness

of the maple syrup), and Buckeye (Chocolate and Peanut Butter)

Please call or text us at 614.602.9876 to place your order.  Thank you!